Guest Stars Charlie Thurston as Roland Erin Neufer as Marian Morash Jefferson Mays as P. Albert Duhamel Tosin Morohunfola as Isaac Danny Burstein as Stanley Lipschitz Rachel Bloom as Elaine Levitch Aaron Serotsky as Hal Bryce Pinkham as John Updike Co Starring Michael Malvesti as Benny Matthew Malone as Ralph Matthew Delamater as Lloyd Nicholas Delany as CBS Rep Jeremiah Kissel as Sander John Noble Barrack as Mark Ryan Richard Doyle as Young Man Jeffrey Kucukistipanoglu voices The Karate Cats