Guest Stars Eddie McClintock as FBI Agent Tim "Sully" Sullivan Chris Conner as Oliver Laurier Valarie Pettiford as Ellen Laskow Darby Stanchfield as Connie Lopata Jonathan Slavin as Hank Belden Colby French as Greg Braley Steve Braun as Ashton Keller Co Starring Sean Patrick Murphy as Forensic Agent Jordan Tartakow as Man Ted Lyde as Police Officer