Guest Stars Colton Gobbo as Mike Jr. Nora McLellan as Principal Sister Rose Richard Clarkin as Dick Dunphy Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll as Father Garcia Nate Penney as Baby Fox Allison Moira Kelly as Linda Mack Furlong as Bis Man Stephen Handrigan as Father Handrigan Eliza King as Employee Katie A. Sullivan as Choir Member Jennifer Nakashima as Choir Member Michelle Chippett as Choir Member Andrea Lane Gardner as Choir Member Julia Halfyard as Choir Member Angela Warren as Choir Member Abra Whitney as Choir Member