Guest Stars April Cameron as Nurse Alyssa Hawks Giacomo Baessato as Jerome Martel Kayla Cromer as Dr. Charlene "Charlie" Lukaitis Bess Armstrong as Eileen Lim David Attar as Rabbi Benjamin Matt McCoy as Scott Carmel Amit as Ronit Dierdre Friel as Lucy's Mom Madison Cooper Higley as Lucy Co Starring Andy Nez as Burly Man Joel Eskildsen as Wiry Man