Guest Stars Conrad Ricamora as Oliver Hampton Kendrick Sampson as Caleb Hapstall Amy Okuda as Catherine Hapstall Sarah Burns as A.D.A. Emily Sinclair John Posey as William Millstone Matt Cohen as Levi Wescott April Grace as Judge Renee Garret Gabrielle Made as Detective Sophia Rodgers Johnnie Battistessa as Young Bonnie
