Guest Stars Sam Elliott voices Mayor Wild West Josh Robert Thompson voices Additional Voices Mike Desilets voices Additional Voices Damien Fahey voices Additional Voices Ralph Garman voices Additional Voices Travis Bowe voices Additional Voices Alec Sulkin voices Jesus Christ John Viener voices Announcer Jay Pharoah voices Additional Voices Chris Regan voices Additional Voices Chris Diamantopoulos voices Additional Voices Danny Smith voices Announcer Mae Whitman voices Emma Rachael MacFarlane voices Time Machine Gary Janetti voices Waiter Steve Callaghan voices Christian Guy in Audience Steve Callaghan voices Audience Member #2 Steve Callaghan voices Follower Alex Carter voices Additional Voices