Special Guest Stars Paul Ben-Victor as Herod Antipas Guest Stars Nina Leon as Mary Salome Aalok Mehta as Barnaby Anne Beyer as Shula Alessandro Colla as Jairus Jorge Franco IV as David Brad Culver as Zebadiah Sophia Blum as Martha Catherine Lidstone as Mary Demetrios Troy as Lazarus Amy Bailey as Joanna Liche Ariza as Gedera Zhaleh Vossough as Veronica Dennis Apergis as Jesse Nick Chinlund as Chuza Richard Fancy as Caiaphas Andrew James Allen as Pontius Pilate Co Starring Ric Sarabia as Shammai Ariel Eliaz as Arnan Angelica Amor as Abigail Taylor Kalupa as Cassandra Richard Tanner as Dunash Shereen Khan as Herodias Sarah J. Bartholomew as Claudia Jake Sidney Cohen as TBD Lonzo Liggins as Crowd Person #1 Georgia Leva as Xiang Iman Nazemzade as TBD Bryce Robin as Daniel