Special Guest Stars John Ortiz as Detective Rogelio Burton Guest Stars Tom Nowicki as Captain Fitzpatrick David St. Louis as Egg Gizel Jimenez as Mel Campesino Charlotte Lawrence as Caitlin Stripling Nina Grollman as Madeline Gonzalo Menendez as Detective Johnny Mendez Scott Glenn as Jim Yancy Lauren Buglioli as Heather McNally Zach Braff as Israel "Izzy" O'Peele Co Starring Anthony Belevtsov as Pestov Matthew Williams as Fed #1 Demi Castro as Fed #2 Tyler Picchi as Simon Carolyn Johnson as Carol Jeffery S. Herman as Dr. Clifford Witt Brian Brightman as Suit Laura Ault as Kyra Brown Brett Cormier as Charles Phinney Tony Bentley as Murphy Gregg Weiner as Other Suit Arian S. Cartaya as Sam O'Peele Ricky Wayne as Dennis Chance Zach Lane as Aidan Adrian Tristan as Newscaster Rachel Comeau as Marisol O'Peele Dave Tommasi as Partner William Ngo as Officer Austin Janowsky as Officiant Veasna Keo as Robber
