Guest Stars Danielle Panabaker as Bonnie Appel Brian Howe as A.D.A. Brad Hewett Colleen Foy as Annabel Brady Gino Anthony Pesi as Sal Gotelli Cameron Goodman as Melody Jilf Reni Santoni as Judge Maurice Vincent Sandra Purpuro as Kiki Parker Loyda Ramos as Juror #1 Co Starring Simone Moore as Female Juror Jenn Korbee as Sasha Kevin Sifuentes as Middle-Aged Guy Bret Anthony as Juror #3 Louis Bernstein as Butcher Drew Butler as Outdoorsman