Guest Stars Rhea Seehorn as Ellen Swatello Nicky Whelan as Charlie Mercedes Colon as Judge Jill Sheehan Thomas Lennon as Harley Walls Lindsey Morgan as Jennifer Katie Gill as Elisa J. Downing as Derek Paulette Williams as Police Detective Hart Bochner as Paul Fitzgerald J.D. Walsh as Allen Slayton Lucan Melkonian as Tony Ventriss Uncredited Rob Lowe as Himself
