Special Guest Stars Bruce Campbell as Chief Dandridge Guest Stars Jessica Treska as Judith Sanders Aline O'Neill as Tonya Elijah Richardson as Cliff Nelson Nolan North as Gene Campbell Eric Tiede as Bob Hartman Jessica Luza as Cassie Dandridge Jennie Page as Abigail Garret Dillahunt as The Reverend Milly Shapiro as Ingrid Drew Waters as Rex Hudson Kevin Saunders as Gilbert Allison Scagliotti as Officer Olsen Jamie Flanagan as Father Mathis Co Starring Ann Marie Gideon as Martha Swift Rice as Principal Cleary Jennifer Yun as Susan Branch Shelli Delgado as Female Townsperson #1 Victoria Baxter as Female Townsperson #2 Robin F. Baker as Male Townsperson #1 John Castle as Male Townsperson #2
