Guest Stars Mackenzie Lintz as Norrie Calvert-Hill Leon Rippy as Ollie Densmore Beth Broderick as Rose Twitchell Ned Bellamy as Reverend Lester Coggins Co Starring John Elvis as Ben Drake Andrew Vogel as Carter Kevin Sizemore as Paul Katie Garfield as Girl #1 Darryl Booker as Townsman #1 Chantelle Mussenden as Girl #2 Nick Basta as Townsman #2 Bill Eudaly as Older Man Deborah Childs as Older Woman