Special Guest Stars Alana De La Garza as Special Agent in Charge Isobel Castile Guest Stars Caroline Harris as Cora Love Steven Williams as Ray Cannon Sr. Paige Davis as Paige Perkins Jackson Kelly as Zach Stolowitz Ronnie Marmo as Robert Tomassi Samuel Farnsworth as Will Haggarty Donna Vivino as Carlotta Tomassi Matt Walton as Mr. Haggarty Georgi James as Caitlyn Baker Kylie Victoria Edwards as Brooke Perkins Co Starring Ja'Siah Young as Caleb Love Robin S. Walker as Principal Gleason Maggie Shirk as Greta Stolowitz Kendall Becerra as Maria Tomassi Alexander Joseph Fox as Matt Aimee Zaleski as Erin Slade Kyle Lamont as Jason Anders Colin Li as Isaac Jason Salmon as Jack Stolowitz