Guest Stars Taylor Anthony Miller as Analyst Kelly Moran Vedette Lim as Analyst Elise Taylor Gibson Frazier as BAU Profiler Eric Piper Runge as Melanie Ortiz April Matthis as NYPD Detective Dashiell Eaves as Tom McGrath Max Monnig as Roy Co Starring Kevin Anton as Foreman Miguel Jarquin-Moreland as Justin Halvorson Kal Mansoor as Tom's Lawyer Eric Coles as Male Jogger Raina Silver as Jennifer Murray Ryan Jacobucci as Finance Bro
