Special Guest Stars Mandy Patinkin as Dr. Noah Wolf Guest Stars Donna Murphy as Dr. Muriel Landon Gray Powell as Dr. Noah Wolf Jaden Waldman as Young Oliver Wolf Mishel Prada as Katie Rodriguez Ted Sutherland as Teen Oliver Stacey Farber as Michelle Simon Webster as Young Oliver Karen Robinson as Betsy Chase Eden Espinosa as Pastor Maria Thomas Co Starring Kiki Hammill as Maya Allen Carson Durven as Gene Pomeroy Henry Falk as Liam Markus Derek Moran as Samuel Thomas Ibrahim Marriott as Choir Member 5 Karolina Dyadchenko as Choir Member 6 Sienna Northwood as Choir Member 16 Sanjali Paruthi as Choir Member 15 Bradley Osusu as Choir Member 14 Chelsea Owusu as Choir Member 13 Isaac De Melo as Choir Member 12 Bethany Simms as Choir Member 11 Alex Kotsopoulos as Choir Member 10 Juliet Brennan as Choir Member 9 Laurel Aikenhead as Choir Member 8 Wareezat Bello as Choir Member 7 Amirah Gonzalez as Choir Member 4 Ameir Otchere as Choir Member 3 Chance McCarthy-Barry as Choir Member 2 Musheara Rodriguez-Dupe as Choir Member 1 Marquesa Edwards as Little Girl
