Special Guest Stars Sarah Michelle Gellar as Tanya Martin Guest Stars Brittany Allen as Laura Moser Aaron Jennings as Clark Sanders Sarah Kinsey as Camilla Figg Eli Sherman as Little Dexter Jasper Lewis as Doris Morgan Isaac Gonzalez Rossi as Gio Martino Jeff Daniel Phillips as Levi Reed Alyssa Limperis as Carol Shears Co Starring Xander Mateo Delatorre as Young Brian Victoria Martzloff as Tiffany Carlye Tamaren as Brandi Silvera Al Coronel as Judge Torres Jeffrey Stubblefield as Alan Barnes Shiva Ayama as D.A. Elaine Zhu Tyler Lofton as Evan Atticus Batacan as Dr. Christian Vandewalker Joy Cooper as Bartender Heather Konowal as Veterinarian Ari Hader as Female Officer Matt Harrison as Male Officer Noel Savoy as Trainer
