Guest Stars Kaitlyn Black as Annabeth Nass Mircea Monroe as Tansy Truitt Peter MacKenzie as Rev. Peter Mayfair Matt Oberg as Scooter McGreevy Debra Jo Rupp as Betsy Maynard Ryan Gaul as Dale King Co Starring Ross Philips as Tom Long Reginald VelJohnson as Dash Dewitt Mallory Moye as Wanda Brandi Burkhardt as Crickett Watts Armelia McQueen as Shula Whitaker John Marshall Jones as Wally Maynard Carla Renata as Susie Collins Joe Massingill as Cody Kim Robillard as Sal Nutter Lindsey Van Horn as Amy-Rose Megan Ferguson as Daisy Deborah Lacey as Madame Van Horn Alan Autry as Todd Gainey Sr. Alexandra Oliver as Marian