Guest Stars Hudson Macready as Ryder Eliza Coupe as Carina Wilson Ken Marino as Charles Lavoie Rory O'Malley as Brett Lewis Jai Rodriguez as Jeff Lewis Kayvon Esmaili as Darius Farzan Irina Dubova as Oksana Petrov Lurie Poston as Bryan Schlotzky Amir Talai as Mark Wilson Co Starring TJ Lee as Officer Lin Kate Boyer as Tara Foley Tom Virtue as Catholic Priest Laura Linda Bradley as Mom Melanie Reif as Annie / Librarian Michael Dearie as Dad Luna Tieu as Binh Pham S. Zylan Brooks as Cynthia Flemmings Mark Bloom as Will Schlotzky Kiff Scholl as Eastern Orthodox Priest Sawyer Holt as Finn Ellia Love as Cocky Four-Year-Old Alejandra Flores as Manuela Torres
