Guest Stars Caleb Foote as Bernard "Randy" Randolf Bobby Moynihan as Woodrow "Woody" Browne Patrick Fischler as SAC Cliff Wheeler Daniel Bellomy as Herman "Herm" Daniels Michael J. Harney as Richard "Dick" Kowalski Eric Normington as NIS Special Agent Roger Murphy Jeff Boehm as NIS Agent Dalton Rafael Castillo as Kenneth "Black Kenny" Simmons Scotty Tovar as Felipe "Flaco" Navarro Co Starring Marisa Baram as Gail Price Aaron Wilton as NIS Special Agent JJ Henneberry Sam Myerson as Matt Dalton Scroggin as Young Kowalski Uncredited Mark Harmon voices Older Leroy Jethro Gibbs