Guest Stars Robert Patrick as Sheriff McDowell Sebastian Roché as Father Renaud Michael Spears as Runs His Horse Jamie McShane as Marshal Kent Brian Konowal as Clive Jeremy Gauna as Pete Plenty Clouds Joy Osmanski as Alice Davis Jennifer Carpenter as US Marshal Mamie Fossett Andy Dispensa as Luca Gilles Marini as Sal Maceo Co Starring Caleb Martin as Dennis Mark Daneri as Dr. Steven Miller Ross Crain as US Marshal Thomas Remy Holt as Madelyn Davis Henry Emde as Matthew Davis Tyler Beardsley as Charlie (Bartender) Patrick Burch as Judge Roy Garrett Derek Russo as Angelo Tom Vera as Beach Gang Member Bobbie Grace as Secretary (Judge Sanders) Olivia Tovar as Ester John Donovan Wilson as Olaf Zack Scott as Chef Lara Hammond as Nurse