Guest Stars Parker Queenan as Young Man / Jamie Danielle Savre as Heather Tollin Callie McClincy as Taylor Reed Paul Schackman as Rabbi Steven Mendel Peter Jacobson as Jacob Lieb Co Starring Scott Daniel Johnson as Darryl Reed Vince Foster as Agent Millen Jason Coviello as Chester Roberts Bethany Geaber as Tierza Braunstein Sarah Borne as Rachel Reed Brittany Wilkerson as Molly Lieb Jacob Wilhelmi as Zev Braunstein AJ Troup as Daniel Brandon Belieu as Burton Kester Ava Mize as Eden Elijah Wood as Elmore Roberts
