Guest Stars Christie Burke as Lorna Matthew Harrison as Dan Jordan Olivia Steele-Falconer as Ramona Eric Breker as Rulon Christina Sicoli as Vonda Andres Collantes as Arturo Jessie Fraser as Josie Ortez Barry W. Levy as Present Day John Rubi Tupper as Little Rena Gracie Mae Gannon as Toddler Erin Erik Kavanagh as Heber Matthew Nelson-Mahood as Aaron Isa Sanchez as Midwife Clayton James as John Vienna Wideman as Baby Erin Jamison Belushi as Agent Marlton Manny Hernandez as Federale Haven Noelle Gin as Kaitlin Vienna Vazquez as Newborn Baby Erin Cadynce Gale as Erin