Guest Stars Mishka Thébaud as Benji Calderone Erin Karpluk as Reba Daniels Anna Chlumsky as Dawn Hudson Nozipho McLean as Rose Co Starring Dani Alvarado as Young Renata Aiyanna Miorin as Young Michelle Anthony Scardera as Anthony James Clayton as Todd Amy Goodmurphy as Detective Haley Dominic Fugere as Undercover Waiter Chloe McKinnon as Sadie Nicole Oliver as Erica Boswell Haylee Turner as Undercover Busser Chris Shields as Detective Mills Nic Walter as Jason Emmanuel Akpoviroro as ATF Agent Denise Johnston as Ms. Yolanda Shay Galor as Jan Donovan
