Guest Stars Kyle MacLachlan as Donald Washberg Jeanne Tripplehorn as Betty Jo Washberg Ryan Kiera Armstrong as Francis Lebon Cody Lightning as Waylon Tracy Letts as Frank Martin Scott Shepherd as Allen Murphy Paul Sparks as Pastor Mark Sternwick Tom McCarthy as Trip Keating Abbie Cobb as Vicky Williams Andre Hyland as Shickford Tisha Campbell as Odette Peter Dinklage as Wendell Co Starring Siena East as Deidra Jude Barnett as Cousin Henry Rachel Crowl as Sally Ken Pomeroy as Pearl Washberg Kerry Malloy as Phil Ray Hurd as Officer Ty Tina Parker as Sandy Garner Lucas McCutchen as Man Blake Blair as Large Skinhead Laura Rankin as Lady with Flowing Robes Jen Pierce as Woman The Big Fish as Surly Doorman Derek Babb as New Skinhead Dakota Kennedy as Rifle Cop
