Guest Stars Ben Doherty as Sam Nance Stephanie Kurtzuba as Donna Kennedy Moyer as Harper Prendergrast Dominic Colón as Breaker Oliver Eisenson as Wyatt Prendergrast Margarita Levieva as Eryn Wilkes Colin Bates as Shane "Reaper" McReynolds Mickey Sumner as Shelley Wilkins Isaach De Bankolé as Father Daniel Elvis Nolasco as Freddie Frias Mireille Enos as Susan Brandis Co Starring Robert Berlin as Julius Andrew Russel as Ethan Brandis Josue Rafael Tejada as DTO Member John Jezior as Agent Easley Chris Mann as FBI Ballistics Expert Robert J Morgalo as Shift Manager Jared Delaney as Barnaby's Bartender Pat DeFusco as Tommy Boyle Irene Wiley as Freddy's Mom Harper Keith as Young Sara Steven Scott Adams as Denny Moser Joe Morelli as State Trooper Liz Priestley as County Paramedic Jacob Berger as Wise Guy Tree Worker Kittson O'Neill as Susie Holbert Brian Gallagher as Corporal Jimmy Masterson Adam Ross Ratcliffe as Statie Corporal Peter Patrikios as Ray Lyman
