Special Guest Stars Chris Parnell as Mario Guest Stars Amber Riley as Mercedes Jones Lauren Potter as Becky Jackson Max Adler as Dave Karofsky Josh Sussman as Jacob Ben Israel Bill A. Jones as Rod Remington Earlene Davis as Andrea Carmichael Michael Lerner as Sidney Greene Chad Buchanan as Bartender Rod McLachlan as News Stand Guy Cyrina Fiallo as Web Critic Tony Colitti as Salvatoire Co Starring John Ainsworth as Barclay Jeff Doucette as NY Times Critic Shaun Brown as Theatre Patron
