Guest Stars Patch Darragh as John Marvin Murdaugh Noah Emmerich as Randy Murdaugh Ramona Floyd as Lynn Goettee Brittany Snow as Mandy Matney Tommy Dewey as Mark Tinsley Mina Sundwall as Brooklynn White Ryan Paynter as Anthony Cook Paul Schneider as Billy Anderson Andrea Powell as Renee Beach Andy Hoff as Phillip Beach Rhoda Griffis as Sandy Smith Tyler DiChiara as Stephen Smith's Friend Ian Christenson as Stephen Smith Co Starring Holly Morris as Christy Murdaugh J.D. Starnes as Tony Satterfield Amye Goussett as Elizabeth Murdaugh Lucy Catharine Haskill as Annette Ursula O. Robinson as Shelley Smith Callan Wilson as Rogan Gibson Winter Andrews as Brian Satterfield Susan Quinones as John Marvin's Daughter Michele Santoro as Alicia Paul Ryden as Judge Hall Jacob Stauff as Jackass Keese Wilson as Delivery Guy Tatiana Piper as Lindsey Kyle Riggs as Miles Angie Dillard as Older Lady Eric Croas as Huge Man in Ball Cap Nickolas Wolf as Teen Boy Brooke Maroon as Game Operator Tyla Harris as Genevieve Kelly Lamor Wilson as Stephanie Smith MJ Wolfe as Guy in Harley Shirt
