Guest Stars Ryan Lane as Travis Marlee Matlin as Melody Bledsoe Rachel Shenton as Lily Summers Sharon Pierre-Louis as Iris Stephanie Nogueras as Natalie Pierce Austin Cauldwell as Josh Padden Bess Armstrong as Professor Marillo Sarah Stouffer as Tess Ritter Sharon Wilkins as Probation Officer Tom Maden as Robbie Nicholson Jocelyn Ayanna as Clerk Ashlee Lapine as Marci