Special Guest Stars Patti LuPone as Rosie Morsch Guest Stars Katharine McPhee as Nora Bayes Jill Hennessy as Mrs. Nesbit Shelby Flannery as Young Marian Gemma McIlhenny as Celia Katherine O'Sullivan as Gretchen Doctor Mikael Powell as Handyman David Pittu as Marius Steven Boyer as Lucky John Higgins as Andrew Carnegie Karen Woditsch as Eliza Zack Fine as Norman's Father Alex Michael Shafer as John Rockefeller Susan Gordon as Linda Cohen Scott Adsit as Stanford White Charley Rowan McCain as Child Rosie Tracy Wilder as Wife Daniel Oreskes as Ludwig Regina Ohashi as Beatrice Maryann Towne as Professor #1 Aaron Latta-Morissette as Young Man in the Back Valéry Lessard as Lilith's Mom Claudia Robinson as Janice Christopher Donohue as Mustache Man Sergio Bernal as Museum Staffer Blair Newman as Young Lilith Beth Goodrich as Cashier Leslie E. Hallowell as Tour Guide Lucas Fried as 11 Year Old Norman Christopher Jehnert as Stable Boy Carla Johnston as Vassar Librarian Samantha Joy Pearlman as Norman's Mother Srini Kumar as Professor's Assistant Tricia Merrick as Laura's Other Friend Jonathan Peacy as Second Creepy Artist Emma Pearson as 8 Year Old Marian Kate Ruddy as Young Nude Woman (Degas in Paris) Miranda Volpe as Laura's Friend George Vezina as Professor #2 Stella Zuniga as Rose Jada German as Lilith's Dance Double Anisha Nagarajan as Lucky's Wife Alexander Blaise as Art Dealer Valorie Hubbard as Old Yard Saler Joe Urla as Mr. Vanderbilt Shaun Taylor-Corbett as Ferdinand Zac Jaffee as Owner of the House Joanne Ryan as Marian's Mom Maria Tucci as Chef / Cook Daniel O'Shea as Creepy Artist Ean Sheehy as Henry's Physician Francis Dumaurier as Jewish Man Jean Brassard as Cousin Degas William Michals as Third Creepy Artist Mishka Yarovoy as Young Norman Bartley Booz as Young Thomas Elizabeth Lande as Laura Rockefeller Ethan Haberfield as Vassar Student #1 Josh Johnston as Vassar Student #1 / College Boy #1 Anni Krueger as Maid #2 Irene Glezos as Museum Director Aramis Merlin as Gunter Janice Hall as Cantor
