Guest Stars Dylan Kingwell as Young Sam Winchester Dylan Everett as Teenage Dean Winchester Anja Savcic as Reese Carrie Genzel as Linda Berman Nate Torrence as Sully Co Starring Scott Gibson as Sparkle Ida Segerhagen as Nicky Eduard Witzke as Weems Benjamin Wosk as Fletcher Jena Skodje as Jenna Berman Isebelle Beech as Zoe Everrett Shea as Mr. Berman