Guest Stars Andy Hallett as Lorne Stephanie Romanov as Lilah Morgan Julie Benz as Darla Christian Kane as Lindsey McDonald Eliza Dushku as Faith Justina Machado as Jo Co Starring Matthew James as Merl Demon Andy Kreiss as Lizard Demon Rob Boltin as Johnny Fontaine Keith Campbell as Club Manager E.J. Gage as Mordar the Bentback Iris Fields as Acting Teacher Jason Frasca as White Guy Glenn David Calloway as Judge