Guest Stars Sheila Larken as Margaret Scully John Finn as Michael Kritschgau Charles Cioffi as Section Chief Scott Blevins Pat Skipper as Bill Scully Jr. James Sutorius as Babcock Matthew Walker as Arlinsky John Oliver as Rolston Co Starring Arnie Walters as Father McCue Barry W. Levy as Vitagliano Steve Makaj as Scott Ostelhoff Nancy Kerr as Agent Hedin Craig Bruhnanski as Saw Operator Rob Freeman as Detective Rempulski