Guest Stars Reed Diamond as Laurence Dominic Amy Acker as Dr. Claire Saunders Miracle Laurie as Mellie / November Liza Lapira as Ivy Aisha Hinds as Loomis Mark Sheppard as Brian Tanaka Patton Oswalt as Joel Mynor Kevin Kilner as Hearn David Barry Gray as Bicks Co Starring Erin Cummings as Staff Member Abby Cooper as Teen Girl Patrick Stinson as Brett Locano Katie Nisa as Blue Collar Guy's Wife T.J. Josefy as Blue Collar Guy Katherine Jacques as Checkout Girl Dalton Grant as Theorist Pam Trotter as Woman Billy Beck as Old Man Kaleti Williams as Head of Security Lydia Blanco as Housewife Jamie Silberhartz as Peasant Blouse Karl Herlinger as Sketchy Guy