Guest Stars Xosha Roquemore as Tamra Webb Mark Duplass as Brendan Deslaurier Anders Holm as Casey Peerson Jay Duplass as Duncan Deslaurier Bill Hader as Tom McDougall Francia Raisa as Katie Co Starring Christopher Sean as Phillip Jim Titus as Brett Tony Evangelista as Frat Bro #1 Uncredited Sammy Courtright as College Student