Special Guest Stars Laura Linney as Charlotte Guest Stars Kirsten Nelson as Ellie Beth Littleford as Creationism Date Rachel Dratch as Horny Date Stacey Travis as Cindy Ann Magnuson as Harvest Elon Gold as Brad Co Starring Amita Balla as Waitress Kate Steele as Teen Date Ellen Ratner as Dress Date Christie Mellor as Woman in Bar Suzanne Lee Singh as Wig Date