Guest Stars Dana Daurey as Heather Tupperman Nicki Aycox as Lily Gallagher Michael Reilly Burke as Brady Pullman David Lee Smith as Paul Rutigliata Allison Mack as Alicia Jordan Brower as Mark Michael Milhoan as Mr. Babbington Brian Poth as Thomas Babbington John Capodice as Carl Rutigliata John Short as Steve Ducey Co Starring Toni DeRose as Patrice Frank Santorelli as Sal Lise Simms as Shelly Steve Stapenhorst as Priest Bobby Jasmin as Large Man #1 Jack McCullough as Construction Worker