Guest Stars Dan Lauria as Paul Celano Richard Beymer as Richard Collins Allison Smith as Allison Palmer Timilee Romolini as MaryBeth Whitman Joel Michaels as Nicholas Ryan Michael Stone as Foreperson Tia Riebling as Lucy Raynor Scheine as Eric Taylor Brandy Lynne Potts as Bartender Kristen Love as Nurse Paul Tranghese as Cop