Guest Stars Vanessa Lengies as Alexa Amanda Detmer as Helen Pritchard Philip Baker Hall as Sheriff James Pritchard Derek Webster as Agent John Strayburn Piers Morgan as Himself Nicky Whelan as Bettina Rod Hallett as Hart Watkins Co Starring Scott Menville voices Arthur Amaree Samnani as Four Year Old Otto Jason Douglas as FBI Interviewer Jason Skeen as Old Prichard 1985 Adam Dietrich as Jittery Burglar John McIntosh as Agent Bech Tanika Cato as Middle Age Woman Daniel Duque-Estrada as Dealer Maggie Parks as Lululemon #1 Priya Hothi as Four Year Old Mary
