Guest Stars René Auberjonois as Mr. McGuire Sophia Mitri Schloss as Jamie Ted Rooney as Sheriff Heyer Co Starring Aparna Brielle as Flirty Waitress Gary Kraus as Naked Mayor Eric Ray Anderson as Walter Joanne Spracklen as Bo Peep Kate Alden as Liza Chrisse Roccaro as Arguing Woman Brendan Quinlan as Arguing Man