Guest Stars Liam James as Young Shawn Kurt Fuller as Dr. Woodrow Juniper "Woody" Strode Freddie Prinze, Jr. as Dennis Gogolack Becky O'Donohue as Molly Gogolack Adam Greydon Reid as Toby Shore Charles Martin Smith as Roy Kessler Co Starring Carlos McCullers, II as Young Gus James Tyce as Thug #1 Kate Gajdosik as Reporter Peter Yunker as Tim Bunting David Gore as Young Dennis Kelly Metzger as Nerdy Woman