Special Guest Stars Rob Estes as Jimmy Mariano Guest Stars Liz Torres as Miss Patty Michael Winters as Taylor Doose Emily Kuroda as Mrs. Kim Teal Redmann as Louise Grant Shelly Cole as Madeline Lynn Adam Brody as Dave Rygalski Jim Jansen as Reverend Archie Skinner Chauncey Leopardi as Kyle Alan Blumenfeld as Rabbi David Barans Ben Falcone as Mr. Brink Co Starring Aris Alvarado as Caesar