Guest Stars Mary Page Keller as Agent Katherine 'Katie' Cole Jodi Lyn O'Keefe as Agent Amanda Gilroy John Rubinstein as Hayden Rawlings Daryl Sabara as Kevin Co Starring Jonathan Runyon as Dan Ash Elizabeth Hendrickson as Amy Cole Dig Wayne as Reverend Jackson Harris Tisha Terrasini Banker as Jackie Powers Laura Leyva as Gracie Hendricks Michael Len as Peter David Pevsner as Michael