Guest Stars Jack Coleman as State Senator Rob Lipton Ben Silverman as Isaac Chris Gethard as Trevor Adam Lustick as Athlead Employee Stephen Colbert as Broccoli Rob Andrew O'Shanick as Treble Nick Cafero as Treble Daniel Amerman as Russell Brandon Borror-Chappel as Treble Kelly Snow as Treble Sean McDonald as Treble Thaddeus John Potter as Treble