Special Guest Stars Jason Alexander as Paul Rothschild Guest Stars Nicholas Brendon as Kevin Lynch Meta Golding as Jordan Todd Paul Michael Glaser as Detective Garrity Ali Landry as Kaylee Robinson Co Starring Gina Garcia Sharp as Agent Gina Sharp Tiffany Espensen as Samantha Brighid Fleming as Jessica Davis Cleveland as Ricky Ellery Sprayberry as Chelsea Robinson Jamie Israel as Student 1 Quonta Beasley as Student 2