Guest Stars Evan Peters as Charlie Hillridge Ann Cusack as Sarah Hillridge Toby Huss as Frank Lynch Brooke Smith as Barbara Lynch Beth Grant as Anita Weld Roycewood Bud Cort as Roger Cameron Protzman as Aimee Lynch Co Starring Bunny Levine as Martha Alton Clemente as Deputy Katlin Mastandrea as Mae Austin Mincks as Stephen Shepherd David Youse as Mr. Shepherd Debra Sullivan as Mrs. Shepherd Grace Savage as News Anchor Mark St. Amant as Jake Hillridge Richard Clarke Larsen as Mr. Hayden