Guest Stars Sterling Beaumon as Jeremy Isabella Murad as Ellie Spicer Ken Meseroll as State Trooper Michael Reilly Burke as Agent Grady Beeks Mare Winningham as Nancy Riverton Kristin Carey as Sandra Bennett Natalie Alyn Lind as Kayla Bennett Kerry O'Malley as Kendra Sayer Stephanie Grant as Amber Riverton Chloe Csengery as Carrie Sayer Cameron Meyer as Ellie's Mom David Goryl as Jake Bennett Evan Dye as Zack Riverton Preston Strother as Sammy Bennett William Cowart as Reverend Louis Hannum