Guest Stars Robert Englund as Detective Gassner Madeleine Martin as Lara Heathridge Juliet Landau as Catherine Heathridge Kyle Gallner as James Heathridge Michaela Carrozzo as Abby Gary Brintz as Bartender Lora Plattner as Chloe Ezra Buzzington as Louis Sills Robert Mukes as Male Visitor Sean T. Krishnan as Dr. Bonds Teddy Vincent as Tiffany Kimberly Westbrook as Sarah Gammon Everette Plen as Mike Georgia Dolenz as Alice Pritchard Chase Mouser as Young James