Guest Stars Esai Morales as BAU Section Chief Mateo Cruz Michael Trucco as Owen McGregor Brett Cullen as Preacher Mills Romi Dias as Deputy Vicky Lorenzana Brady Smith as Deputy Marty Bennett Kevin E. West as Sheriff Coleman Co Starring Tamara Clatterbuck as Dinah Stidham Cyrina Fiallo as Jesse Moore Tom Proctor as Dusty Roberta Bassin as Linda Ashley Dulaney as Abigail Jones Dougald Park as Principal McIntyre Sarah Stouffer as Tabitha Ryan Amy Schloerb as Carrie Lawson Veronica Roy as Belinda Clark Gary Cairns II as Travis Brice Fisher as Bobby Shawn Law as Albert Franklin