Guest Stars Jenny O'Hara as Janet Heffernan Dakin Matthews as Joe Heffernan Tyler Hendrickson as Young Doug Joe Flaherty as Father McAndrew Alexa Nikolas as Young Carrie Greg Wrangler as Coach Nikki Tyler-Flynn as Wedding Coordinator Andrea Sabesin as Suzanne Jessica Alyce Merrill as Becky Vanessa Kinan as Rita Uncredited Tyler Hendrickson as Young Danny
