Guest Stars Jenny O'Hara voices Janet Heffernan Dakin Matthews voices Joe Heffernan Nick Bakay as Father Melley Benjamin King as Larry Stephanie Brown as Cathy Aaron Page as Choir Member #1 Deena Brooks as Choir Member #6 Dennis Howard voices Announcer Tessa Grady as Choir Member #5 Ryan Dyer as Choir Member #2 David Bachman as Choir Member #3 Casey Hands as Choir Member #4 Annmarie Rizzo as Choir Member #7
